Could adding a little straw to calf diets help young animals grow more? New research suggests it may. In a trial involving 128 male calves, those receiving diets with 4% or 8% straw consumed more starter and were heavier around weaning than calves fed no additional straw.
The findings offer new insight into how structural fiber may influence calf starter intake, rumen development and growth during the transition from milk to solid feed. However, there were no observed differences in diarrhea or respiratory disease, underscoring the limits of what dietary fiber can accomplish.
The study, led by Dr. Hanne Goetz, consultant with ACER Consulting, followed calves at a commercial calf-rearing facility, comparing diets containing 0%, 4% or 8% straw.
The Role of Fiber in Rumen Development
Calves are born with an underdeveloped rumen and must transition from a primarily milk-based diet to solid feed. Calf starters typically contain rapidly fermentable carbohydrates that produce volatile fatty acids during fermentation. Without sufficient structural fiber, this fermentation can contribute to lower rumen pH.
“If we are not including enough fiber in the diet, we see less rumination in these calves, less saliva being produced and ultimately a lower rumen pH,” Goetz explains.
A 2025 meta-analysis examining 36 studies and 86 treatment comparisons found that forage inclusion increased rumen pH during both preweaning and postweaning periods.
The analysis also identified behavioral benefits.
“Providing forage significantly reduced non-nutritive oral behaviors during both the pre-weaning and the post-weaning phase,” Goetz says.
Together, these findings suggest that structural fiber supports both rumen function and normal feeding behavior. The remaining question is how much is needed without compromising the energy density of the diet.
Straw Inclusion and Calf Growth
That question helped drive Goetz’s calf work.
Goetz and her team randomized 128 male calves, arriving at approximately one week of age, to diets containing 0%, 4% or 8% straw. They monitored starter and water intake, growth, feed efficiency and health, following the calves through the production period.
Starter intake began to separate among treatment groups around day 42. Calves receiving either level of straw consumed more starter than calves receiving none, with the differences continuing after weaning.
Following weaning, calves in the 4% straw group consumed just over 7 kilograms more starter per week than controls. Calves receiving 8% straw consumed approximately 5.5 kilograms more per week.
The increased intake was accompanied by differences in body weight. All three groups started at approximately 48 kilograms, but their growth curves began to separate after 49 days on trial.
By day 84, calves receiving 4% straw were nearly 14 kilograms heavier than controls, and those receiving 8% straw weighed just over 11 kilograms more.
“What this tells us is that any of the benefits of the straw inclusion on average daily gain is mostly the result of what’s going on there right around the time of weaning and not necessarily more average daily gain throughout the entire growth period,” Goetz notes.
Feed efficiency was similar among groups before weaning but was slightly lower in straw-fed calves after weaning, suggesting a trade-off alongside the increased intake and growth.
Does Adding Fiber Reduce Calfhood Disease?
Despite the differences in starter intake and body weight, Goetz found no detectable differences in diarrhea or respiratory disease among the three treatment groups.
“We didn’t see any effect of providing straw on those health outcomes,” Goetz says.
Approximately 62% to 67% of calves across all groups were treated for diarrhea.
The findings suggest that fiber inclusion should not be viewed as a disease-prevention strategy. Its potential benefits for rumen function and growth did not translate into fewer cases of common calfhood diseases in this trial.
Finding the Right Balance of Dietary Fiber
More forage is not necessarily better. The 2025 meta-analysis identified a relationship between forage inclusion and total dry matter intake, with the response improving up to approximately 12% forage inclusion before beginning to decline. Beyond that point, energy dilution may start to offset the benefits of additional fiber.
“We’re not necessarily just trying to maximize forage inclusion in our diets, but rather to optimize its inclusion to meet a specific need,” Goetz emphasizes.
In Goetz’s work, the 4% and 8% straw groups had relatively similar performance responses, suggesting higher inclusion did not necessarily deliver additional benefits.
Forage selection and feeding methods also depend on the broader ration. Hay and straw vary in nutritional composition and are not directly interchangeable.
“They can definitely work just depending on your specific situation,” Goetz says. She emphasizes that producers should consider the entire feeding program because “there’s no universally superior forage or processing method.”
Structural fiber deserves a place in calf nutrition. The challenge is finding the right balance: enough structural fiber to support rumen development without sacrificing the energy calves need to grow.


