Dairy producers have made substantial progress in controlling mastitis. Bulk tank somatic cell counts have declined over the past two decades, reflecting improvements in management, housing, milking practices and udder health. Yet low bulk tank numbers can create a misleading sense of security: mastitis can remain a persistent herd-level challenge even when milk quality indicators look strong. This was the topic of discussion during a recent Badger Dairy Insight webinar.
“Mastitis remains a problem on virtually every farm, and every farm requires daily work to prevent it,” says Dr. Pamela Ruegg, David J. Ellis Professor of Antimicrobial Resistance and Large Animal Clinical Sciences in the College of Veterinary Medicine at Michigan State University.
Ruegg points to data from 37 large Wisconsin dairy farms, most of which had bulk tank SCC below 150,000 cells/mL. Even in herds with bulk tank counts between 150,000 and 175,000 cells/mL, she found that 18% to 20% of cows had subclinical mastitis based on individual somatic cell count records.
For larger herds, bulk tank SCC can be an insensitive indicator of the number of individual cows affected. A relatively low tank count does not necessarily mean that subclinical infections have been eliminated or that every group of cows is performing well.
The consequences extend beyond the SCC report. Subclinical mastitis can reduce milk production, increase the likelihood of clinical cases, affect fertility and contribute to culling. Dr. Ruegg thinks of this in terms of a 1,000-cow herd:
“If you’ve got 20% of your cows with subclinical mastitis, that’s 200 cows that have all the problems associated with subclinical mastitis. They produce less milk. They have more clinical mastitis. They have reduced fertility. They’re more likely to be culled.”
This provides a reason to look beyond the bulk tank. Individual cow SCC records, reviewed consistently, can help identify the subclinical burden that herd-level numbers may conceal.
The Mastitis Pathogen Picture Has Changed
The organisms driving mastitis challenges have also shifted. Ruegg says the dairy industry has made substantial progress against contagious pathogens such as Streptococcus agalactiae and Staphylococcus aureus. Those organisms have not disappeared, but they are less commonly the dominant problem in many herds.
“When I started in practice in the ‘80s, most of the herds had high cell counts and most of them were caused by Staph aureus. Today that’s unusual,” she says.
In many modern dairy systems, environmental pathogens have become a greater part of the picture. Ruegg identifies environmental streptococci, Lactococcus species and non-aureus staphylococci among the organisms encountered in herds, along with gram-negative pathogens such as Escherichia coli and Klebsiella. The latter are more commonly associated with clinical rather than subclinical mastitis.
Research from Wisconsin offers another look at the diversity of organisms found in herds with low bulk tank SCC. In a study of 14 dairy farms with bulk tank SCC at or below 150,000 cells/mL, researchers examined milk samples from cows selected because of elevated individual SCC. Among samples with an identifiable microbial growth, non-aureus staphylococci were common, while Enterococcus, Lactococcus and environmental streptococci were also recovered.
The study should be interpreted within its sampling design: cows were selected based on elevated SCC, so the findings do not represent the prevalence of pathogens across all cows or quarters in those herds. They do, however, illustrate the range of organisms that can be present in cows with subclinical mastitis, even on farms with low bulk tank counts.
Ruegg also notes that some herds face less familiar challenges, including Mycoplasma bovis and Prototheca. The pathogen mix can vary considerably among farms, reinforcing the need for herd-specific investigation rather than assuming every elevated SCC or clinical case has the same cause.
Prevention Depends on Consistent Execution
Despite changes in herd size, housing and technology, Ruegg’s leading prevention priorities remain familiar: effective pre- and postmilking teat disinfection, transition-cow management and identifying cows with chronic infections.
Teat dipping remains one of the most cost-effective ways to prevent new intramammary infections, but its effectiveness depends on how consistently it is performed. Applying disinfectant is a routine task, yet ensuring every teat receives adequate coverage at every milking can be difficult, particularly when farms rely on automated systems.
Ruegg encountered a recent example on a farm struggling with elevated SCC. The dairy had two robotic teat-dipping systems, but both had been turned off. The farm had returned to manual dipping because the automated equipment was not consistently covering teats as needed.
The experience illustrates a potential weakness in relying on technology without verifying its performance. Automation can reduce repetitive labor, but it does not remove the need to monitor whether a preventive practice is actually being carried out effectively. A system may be operating as designed without delivering the result the herd needs.
“Technology is amazing when it works,” Ruegg says, emphasizing the need to check that teats are being covered properly.That means evaluating the results of automated teat dipping rather than assuming the equipment is doing the job. If coverage is inconsistent, the process needs to be adjusted. In this case, that meant returning to manual dipping.
Ruegg points to research showing that effective pre- and postmilking teat dipping can each contribute to a 50% reduction in new intramammary infections. The potential return is substantial, but only when the practice is implemented consistently. The lesson is straightforward: investing in automation is not the same as investing in effective mastitis prevention.
Transition cows are another priority. Around calving and early lactation, cows experience physiological and management changes that can increase their susceptibility to infection. Group movements, metabolic challenges and exposure to pathogens can compound that vulnerability.
“Investing in management and preventive strategies to have a clean, dry, adequately spaced place for the calving line and to have udders that are absolutely clean when they calve is a huge investment during that critical period,” Ruegg says.
These measures require attention to the day-to-day conditions cows experience, not simply a written protocol. Bedding management, calving-area hygiene and the routines followed by employees all contribute to the level of exposure.
Chronic Cows Need a Management Decision
Ruegg also prioritizes identifying cows with chronic mastitis and deciding how they should be managed. These cows can serve as reservoirs of infection for other animals, while also experiencing repeated health and production challenges themselves.
She describes chronic cows as animals with two consecutive SCC tests above 200,000 cells/mL and/or more than two clinical mastitis cases in a lactation. Individual cow records can help identify these animals before they continue contributing to the herd’s infection burden.
Treatment is not necessarily the best response.
“Very few of those cows are going to benefit from treatment,” Ruegg says. “You’re going to be looking at other things such as segregation, drying up quarters, occasionally you might want to cull the cows, things like that, but not treatment because very few of these cows will respond to treatment.”
Those decisions require a combination of clinical judgment and herd-level perspective. The goal is to consider the likelihood of recovery, the cow’s production and future potential, and the risk she poses to other animals.
Milk Quality is a People-Management Issue
“Managing cows is all about people,” Ruegg says. “The most important thing that discriminates between herds that always have high-quality milk and herds that struggle is the attitude of the farm owner.”
Mastitis prevention ultimately depends on whether the farm’s routines are carried out consistently. Teat disinfection, transition-cow care and chronic-cow decisions all require communication, training and follow-through.
Low bulk tank SCC is a meaningful achievement, but it is only one measure of udder health. Individual cow records, pathogen investigation and consistent prevention practices help reveal what the tank cannot. For veterinarians working with high-performing herds, that closer look can uncover opportunities to reduce subclinical infections, prevent new cases and keep milk quality moving in the right direction.


